Hazelnut Extract Substitutes

When embarking on baking projects or crafting desserts, the distinctive, nutty flavor of hazelnut extract is sometimes a key ingredient. However, you might find yourself in a situation where hazelnut extract isn’t readily available. Whether due to allergies, personal preferences, or simply an empty pantry, knowing how to substitute this ingredient without compromising taste can be essential for any cook.

Vanilla extract is frequently recommended as a substitute due to its sweet and aromatic quality that complements a variety of recipes. It offers a warm and comforting flavor that pairs well with baked goods and other sweet treats. If you’re looking for a substitute that can replicate the nutty profile more closely, extracts like almond or possibly cashew extract could serve as viable alternatives. These can bring similar notes to dishes, making them ideal substitutes in the absence of hazelnut extract.

Understanding Hazelnut Extract

Ask the Test Kitchen: Can I Use Hazelnut Extract as a Vanilla Extract Substitute?

Hazelnut extract is a concentrated flavoring used to impart the nutty, sweet essence of hazelnuts into various culinary concoctions. From desserts to beverages, understanding its attributes and applications can enhance your cooking and baking repertoire.

Nutritional Profile

Hazelnut extract, derived from hazelnuts, carries hints of the nutritional benefits found in its source nut. While not as nutrient-dense due to its concentrated nature, hazelnuts are rich in vitamin E, monounsaturated fats, fiber, as well as essential vitamins and minerals. The extract also contains antioxidants often associated with the whole nut.

Culinary Uses

In your kitchen, you can use hazelnut extract to add a unique flavor to baked goods and desserts. Its intense sweetness and nutty profile are particularly popular in creating specialty beverages and enriching the taste of homemade frostings or fillings.

Flavor Characteristics

The flavor of hazelnut extract is distinctly nutty, often perceived as sweet and mild, though it can exhibit a slightly bitter undertone. This complexity allows for versatile use across sweet and savory dishes alike.

Allergy Considerations

If you’re catering to individuals with nut allergies or sensitivities, it’s pivotal to avoid hazelnut extract since it poses the same allergenic risks as hazelnuts. Substitutes like hazelnut butter or hazelnut oil would also not be suitable for those allergic to nuts.

Hazelnut Extract in Commercial Products

Commercially, hazelnut extract is a frequent addition to products like chocolate spreads such as Nutella. It imbues a deep, rounded hazelnut tone to various off-the-shelf items, elevating their appeal through its flavorful enhancement.

Hazelnut to Extract Ratio in Recipes

When using hazelnut extract in recipes, remember that it is a concentrated flavoring. A general guideline is to start with 1/4 teaspoon of extract to replace 1 tablespoon of ground hazelnuts, adjusting according to taste preference and recipe requirements.

Texture Contributions to Dishes

While hazelnut extract won’t replicate the crunchy or crispy texture you might desire from hazelnuts, it perfectly conveys the essence of the nut’s flavor. To compensate for texture, consider adding chopped nuts or seeds aligned with the dish’s taste profile and desired consistency.

Common Substitutes for Hazelnut Extract

🔵 How To Make Hazelnut Liqueur 'Frangelico' Recipe

When your recipe calls for hazelnut extract and you find yourself without any, there are several alternative options that can mimic its sweet, nutty flavor. Each substitute offers a distinct profile that can enhance your desserts or savory dishes.

Almond Extract

Almond extract is a popular substitute for hazelnut extract due to its sweet, similarly nutty flavor. Use it in baking to imbue cakes and other treats with a rich taste. A general guideline is to use an equal amount of almond extract as hazelnut extract.

Vanilla Extract

Vanilla extract, known for its warm and comforting taste, can replace hazelnut extract, particularly in sweet baked goods. Its versatile and aromatic flavor can add depth to cakes and desserts. Substitute vanilla extract in the same quantity as the hazelnut extract called for in the recipe.

Chocolate Flavorings

  • Chocolate spread: Chocolate spreads, often combined with hazelnuts like Nutella, can be used in place of hazelnut extract to give a chocolatey-nutty flavor to desserts.
  • Candy chips: Melted chocolate or chocolate candy chips also serve as a flavorful alternative, providing the required sweetness and a complementary taste.

Nut-Based Alternatives

For a substitute that preserves the nutty flavor in your dishes, consider using finely ground or processed nuts such as:

  • Macadamia nuts
  • Cashews
  • Pecans
  • Walnuts

These nuts offer a rich taste, protein, and healthy fats. Opt for a one-to-one swap by volume or weight based on the recipe’s requirements.

Seed and Nut Free Options

If you’re addressing nut allergies or prefer to avoid nuts, seeds can step in as a substitute:

  • Sunflower seeds
  • Pumpkin seeds
  • Sesame seeds

These seeds can be ground and used as a textural element with a subtle nutty hint.

Other Flavoring Oils and Extracts

Beyond typical nut flavors, other extracts and flavoring oils possess unique flavor compounds that can replace hazelnut extract. Experiment with the quantity, as their intensity might differ from that of hazelnut extract.

Coffee-Like Substitutes

For a deeper, more bitter note in desserts and beverages, a coffee-like powder or extract can serve as a substitute. This can be especially effective in recipes where a roasted flavor complements the overall dish.

Substitutes in Different Types of Recipes

Best Substitutes For Vanilla In Cooking

When your recipe calls for hazelnut extract and you find yourself without it, fear not; a plethora of substitutes can help you maintain the intended flavors and textures across a variety of dishes.

Desserts and Sweet Baking

For cakes, cookies, and pies, vanilla extract is a reliable substitute, imparting a warm and aromatic essence. It pairs wonderfully with sweet recipes, adding a familiar, comforting taste to your baking. If you’re making a frosting or a dish where the nutty flavor needs to stand out, consider using Nutella. This hazelnut-chocolate spread delivers both sweetness and the desired hazelnut flavoring.

  • Vanilla Extract: Sweet and aromatic, great for baked goods.
  • Nutella: Provides sweetness and hazelnut flavor, suitable for frostings and dessert recipes.

Breads and Pastries

Breads and pastries benefit from substitutes that complement their texture. For a mild, nutty taste and buttery texture, chopped almonds can be used in equal measure to hazelnuts. If you seek a substitute for hazelnut extract specifically, opt for almond extract; it provides a similar nutty profile, particularly effective in breads and granola.

  • Chopped Almonds: Use the same amount as hazelnuts; mild nutty taste.
  • Almond Extract: A drop can replace hazelnut extract for a nutty flavor.

Savory Dishes and Salads

In savory dishes and salads where hazelnut flavoring provides a nutty dimension, toasted sesame oil or sunflower seeds can offer a similar texture and taste. Enhance salad dressings with a pinch of ground nuts or cashew butter for added richness and depth.

  • Toasted Sesame Oil: Nutty flavor, particularly good for dressings and marinades.
  • Sunflower Seeds: Add for a crunchy texture in salads and savory dishes.

Beverages and Spread

When your beverage or spread recipe calls for a touch of hazelnut sweetness, hazelnut syrup can be a direct substitute for extract, tailoring the intensity to your liking. If crafting a spread, consider melding hazelnut butter into your creations for a robust infusion of flavor.

  • Hazelnut Syrup: Use sparingly to imbue beverages with a sweet, nutty essence.
  • Hazelnut Butter: Incorporate into spreads for a direct hazelnut flavor.

Frequently Asked Questions

This section addresses common queries about substituting hazelnut extract in your cooking and baking endeavors, ensuring you can still achieve that distinct, nutty flavor when the extract is not at hand.

What alternative ingredients can provide a similar flavor to hazelnut in baked goods?

You can use almond extract or vanilla extract as substitutes for hazelnut extract. These alternatives add a sweet and aromatic touch to your baked goods, mimicking the essence of hazelnut flavor.

Can hazelnut oil be used as a replacement for hazelnut extract in recipes, and if so, what is the recommended ratio?

Yes, you can replace hazelnut extract with hazelnut oil. Since the oil is less concentrated than the extract, a general guideline is to use twice the amount of oil as you would extract.

What options are available for replicating the taste of hazelnut in recipes when the extract is unavailable?

Opt for hazelnut spreads like Nutella, hazelnut butter, or similar nuts like almonds or macadamia nuts to recreate the flavor profile of hazelnuts in your recipes.

Are there any companies that produce hazelnut flavoring extracts available in the market?

Several companies manufacture hazelnut flavoring extracts, available both in retail stores and through online merchants. Research brands to find one that suits your cooking needs and flavor preferences.

How can I replace hazelnut syrup in a recipe without compromising the intended flavor profile?

You can swap hazelnut syrup with hazelnut extract or a mix of sugar syrup and a few drops of almond extract. This combination can help maintain the sweet nuttiness in your dish.

What are some common flavorings that can mimic the taste of hazelnut in various culinary applications?

Apart from almond extract and vanilla extract, consider using praline paste or frangelico, a hazelnut liqueur, to provide a comparable hazelnut flavor in both sweet and savory applications.

Follow Us
Cassie brings decades of experience to the Kitchen Community. She is a noted chef and avid gardener. Her new book "Healthy Eating Through the Garden" will be released shortly. When not writing or speaking about food and gardens Cassie can be found puttering around farmer's markets and greenhouses looking for the next great idea.
Cassie Marshall
Follow Us