Brie vs Camembert

In the world of soft French cheeses, brie and camembert hold prestigious positions for their creamy textures and distinctive flavors. You might find yourself at a cheese counter, faced with the decision between the two, and the subtle differences can influence your choice.

Both cheeses come with pale interiors surrounded by edible rinds, a result of similar soft-ripening processes. Yet, they are not interchangeable.

Understanding these nuances will enhance your culinary experiences and help you make informed selections to please your palate.

Brie and Camembert wheels sit on a rustic wooden board, surrounded by grapes and crackers

The origin of each cheese is a good starting point. Brie originates from the Île-de-France region, while Camembert hails from Normandy.

This geographic distinction goes beyond locale; it influences the milk used, the precise methods of creation, and the history imbued in each wedge.

Brie often comes in larger wheels, making it a common sight on cheese boards, while camembert’s smaller size is perfect for individual servings or smaller groups.

When tasting, your senses will parse more than just earthiness and creaminess.

Brie generally offers a milder flavor and higher milk fat content, which gives it a rich, buttery essence.

Camembert, on the other hand, presents a deeper, often more intense flavor profile and denser texture that can reveal rustic notes and a strong, sometimes pungent aroma.

The right choice depends on your taste preferences and the context of your meal.

Whether enjoyed as part of a charcuterie board or used in cooking, both brie and camembert can provide a delightful French touch to your dining experience.

Origins and History

A rustic French countryside with rolling hills, a quaint dairy farm, and aged oak barrels for cheese aging

When you explore the world of French cheese, you’ll find that Brie and Camembert both have rich histories rooted in tradition and geography, reflecting their unique cultural heritages within France.

Origins of Brie

Brie, your creamy, smooth cheese, originates from the Île-de-France region. The departments of Seine-et-Marne, Loiret, Aube, Marne, Haut-Marne, Yonne, and Meuse have had a long association with the production of Brie.

With records dating as far back as the 8th century, this French cheese has been synonymous with the area surrounding Paris. Over the centuries, Brie has been refined through a designation of origin (AOC) status for varieties like Brie de Meaux.

Origins of Camembert

Your soft Camembert comes from the Normandy region, specifically the picturesque village of Camembert in the department of Orne.

Legend credits Marie Harel, a farmer in Normandy, with creating the cheese in 1791, during the French Revolution.

Camembert gained an AOC status, protecting its traditional manufacturing processes, ensuring that true Camembert is always made with milk from the Normandy region.

Historical Significance

Historically, Brie was considered a luxury item mostly enjoyed by royalty and the nobility. It earned the reputation of the “Cheese of Kings and Queens” due to its popularity among the French elite and even foreign royalty.

During the Middle Ages, monks were key players in refining the production of Brie.

Conversely, Camembert’s claim to historical fame is its association with the common people during the French Revolution and later its distribution to French troops during World War I, which bolstered its popularity throughout the country.

Classification and Designation

In the world of fine cheeses, Brie and Camembert stand distinguished not just by their creamy textures and rich flavors but also by their protected titles, which are hallmarks of their authenticity and quality.

Protected Designation of Origin

Camembert de Normandie and Brie de Meaux are not just names; they denote cheeses with a Protected Designation of Origin (PDO), a label that assures you of their geographic authenticity and traditional production.

For instance, Camembert cheese with a PDO label guarantees that it was made and matured in the Normandy region using specific methods.

  • Camembert de Normandie: PDO since 1983
  • Brie de Meaux: PDO since 1980

These designations protect the reputation of regional foods, promote rural and agricultural activity, and help consumers by informing them about the specific character of the products.

AOC Classification

In addition to the PDO, the French have their own system of appellation called the Appellation d’Origine Contrôlée (AOC).

This certification is similar to PDO and is specific to France, ensuring that the cheese you savor adheres to strict manufacturing processes and geographic origins.

  • Brie Cheese: Among the various types of Brie, Brie de Meaux has the esteemed AOC classification, ensuring it is produced according to long-standing traditional methods.
  • Camembert Cheese: Likewise, Camembert de Normandie benefits from the stringent AOC regulations, which preserve its unique local identity garnered from Norman cows and the particular microflora of the region.

These classifications are not merely labels but your assurance that when you choose Brie de Meaux or Camembert de Normandie, you are experiencing a product deeply rooted in its terroir and heritage.

Characteristics of Brie and Camembert

Brie and Camembert are iconic French cheeses celebrated for their distinctive characteristics. As you explore their textures and flavors, notice the nuances of their rinds and the variety among both cheeses.

Texture and Flavor

  • Brie: You’ll find Brie to be softer and creamier with a buttery taste. Its flavor profile includes hints of fruit and nuts, leaning towards milder nuances as it ripens. Aspect Brie Texture Creamy and runny Flavor Buttery, with fruity notes
  • Camembert: In comparison, Camembert offers a firmer texture, though still soft, and an intense taste. Earthy and mushroomy tones become pronounced with age. Aspect Camembert Texture Denser and firmer Flavor Earthy, with mushroom notes

Rind Difference

Camembert and Brie are both adorned with a white, bloomy rind that is edible and adds to their respective taste profiles.

The rind of Brie is generally thin and flavorsome, while Camembert’s rind is thicker and contributes to its earthy aroma.

  • Brie:
    • Thin, edible rind
    • Adds a subtle flavor to the cheese
  • Camembert:
    • Thicker rind
    • Enhances the cheese with a richer earthiness

Variations of Brie and Camembert

Variations in these cheeses arise as a result of differences in milk fat content and aging processes.

Brie typically has a 60% milk fat, which can go above 75% in the case of triple-cream Brie, influencing a paler interior as it ripens.

  • Brie Variations:
    • Triple-cream Brie, with a milk fat content over 75%
    • Classic Brie with a 60% milk fat content

Camembert, starting at 45% milk fat, develops its firm texture and notable pale yellow core as it ages.

  • Camembert Variations:
    • Traditional Camembert de Normandie
    • Other regional varieties with 45% milk fat content

Production Methods

In crafting Brie and Camembert, the specifics of milk selection, cheesemaking techniques, and maturation processes are paramount to the distinct textures and flavors of these cheeses.

Milk and Ingredients

Your journey through the production methods begins with milk, the fundamental ingredient. Both cheeses traditionally use cow’s milk: Brie often incorporates added cream for a richer profile.

Camembert, on the other hand, sticks to whole milk yielding a deeper flavor.

The milk can be either pasteurized or unpasteurized, with the latter contributing to a more complex taste due to the presence of local bacteria.

A lactic starter is introduced to the milk alongside Penicillium camemberti, the mold responsible for developing the cheeses’ characteristic bloomy rind.

In the realm of soft-ripened cheeses, this rind is not just for texture but also serves as an incubator for the flavor.

Cheesemaking Techniques

Upon adding the lactic starters and molds, the milk begins to curdle. For Brie and Camembert, the curd is carefully ladled into molds.

This gentle process ensures a soft and delicate cheese structure. The whey is drained slowly, without pressing, preserving the moisture content which contributes to the cheese’s creaminess.

Aging and Maturation

Finally, your attention turns to how these cheeses are aged.

They are both aged under controlled conditions, but Camembert usually has a shorter aging period, resulting in a more intense flavor compared to its counterpart, Brie.

Aged typically for less than 60 days, these cheeses develop their soft interior and velvety rind.

As they mature, they are turned regularly to assure an even distribution of the Penicillium camemberti and other molds that form the rind and influence the interior flavor and texture.

Tasting and Serving

When you savor Brie and Camembert, your experience is largely shaped by their distinctive flavor profiles, ideal pairings, and the temperatures at which you serve them.

Flavor Profile

Brie: You’ll find Brie to be creamy with a mild, buttery flavor. It may contain hints of nuttiness and a touch of sweetness.

Due to its larger size and higher fat content, Brie has a softer taste.

Camembert: In comparison, Camembert offers a more pronounced, earthy flavor with a notable intensity. You might detect the taste of mushrooms, and the smaller wheels contribute to its stronger profile.

Pairings and Combinations

  • Fruits: Both cheeses pair well with fruits like apples, pears, and grapes.
  • Breads and Crackers: Serve them with crusty bread or crackers for a contrasting texture.
  • Nuts: Almonds or walnuts can complement their creaminess.
  • Drinks: Enjoy Brie or Camembert with champagne or red wine, which can balance their rich flavors.
  • Cheese Board: When building a cheese board, include both to offer a range of flavors and textures.

Serving Temperatures

The best way to serve Brie or Camembert is at room temperature. This allows you to fully appreciate their respective flavors and creamy consistency.

Take them out of the refrigerator about 30 minutes before serving to ensure optimal taste.

Culinary Applications

While Brie and Camembert are both celebrated French cheeses, their unique characteristics lend themselves to different culinary uses. Whether incorporated into recipes or served on cheese boards, these cheeses add a sophisticated touch to your dishes.

Recipes with Brie

Brie’s creamy texture makes it versatile in the kitchen. When baked, it becomes even more gooey and can serve as a sumptuous dip.

  • Brie en Croute: Wrap a wheel of Brie in puff pastry with raspberry preserves and bake until golden.
  • Brie and Apple Tart: Layer slices of Brie with apple on a tart shell and bake for a savory-sweet treat.

For a casual snack, you could simply place slices of Brie on a cheese board accompanied by fruit and nuts.

Recipes with Camembert

Camembert has a slightly deeper flavor profile that intensifies when warmed, making it ideal for hearty dishes.

  • Baked Camembert: Top a wheel with garlic, rosemary, and bake it until melted.
  • Camembert Mashed Potatoes: Blend Camembert into your mashed potatoes for a creamier texture.

Serve your baked Camembert as the centerpiece of a cheese board to impress your guests with a rich fondue-like experience.

Preparation Techniques

Learning the correct way to prepare these cheeses will maximize their flavors and textures in your food.

  • Cutting: Serve Brie and Camembert in small wedges to preserve the shape of the wheel and ensure each piece has both rind and creamier center.
  • Serving Temperature: Bring to room temperature before serving to enhance their creamier texture and complex flavors.

Nutritional Aspects

A platter with brie and camembert, surrounded by grapes, crackers, and nuts. The brie is creamy and pale, while the camembert is soft and slightly pungent

When considering Brie and Camembert, you’ll find both cheeses are loved for their creamy textures and distinctive tastes. Your focus should be on their nutritional content, particularly the fat and protein content, as well as the health considerations associated with these French delicacies.

Fat and Protein Content


  • Fat: Higher fat content (around 60% milk fat)
  • Protein: Contains ample protein which is essential for body repair and maintenance


  • Fat: Slightly less fat than Brie (approximately 45% milk fat)
  • Protein: Comparable protein content to Brie, contributing to its similar texture

Both cheeses have variations like triple-cream versions, where the milk fat content can be above 75%, enhancing their rich and indulgent profiles. You might notice the differences in their characteristics, with Brie’s typically richer and more buttery flavor against Camembert’s more intense, nutty taste.

Health Considerations

Brie and Camembert are high in calcium and vitamins such as B12 and A, supporting bone health, energy production, and more.

However, due to their fat content, moderation is key if you’re monitoring your fat intake.

Additionally, the probiotics present in these cheeses can contribute positively to your gut health.

Remember that the rich flavors—fruity for Brie and nuttier for Camembert—come with a high-fat content, so pair them with other foods keeping your overall dietary balance in mind.

Consumer Information

When selecting between Brie and Camembert cheeses, consider aspects such as size, milk fat content, and region of origin to make an informed purchase. Proper storage and handling are crucial for maintaining the quality and flavor profiles of these delicate cheeses.

Buying Tips

  • Size: Brie typically comes in larger wheels, often ranging from 9 to 17 inches in diameter, while Camembert wheels are smaller at about 5 inches. “Brie de Meaux” and “Brie de Melun” are the authentic French varieties, whereas “Camembert de Normandie” is the appellation for true Camembert. If you find a Brie labeled as “baby Brie,” it will be closer in size to Camembert.
  • Milk Fat: The fat content varies with Brie normally having a higher milk fat percentage around 60%, making it creamier, whereas Camembert generally contains about 45% milk fat. There are also triple-cream versions of each cheese for a richer experience.
  • Pasteurization: Seek out “Brie de Meaux” or “Camembert de Normandie” for unpasteurized versions, which are richer in flavor. Pasteurized versions are more common in countries with restrictions on raw milk cheeses.
  • Authenticity: Both cheeses should ideally come in a wooden box, which helps to maintain their shape and integrity.

Storage and Handling

  • Temperature: Store these cheeses in the coldest part of your refrigerator until ready to serve. For the best flavor and texture, allow them to come to room temperature for approximately one hour before consuming.
  • Humidity: Keep the cheese in its original packaging if possible, or wrap it in parchment paper, then loosely in plastic wrap to maintain proper humidity.
  • Shelf Life: Brie and Camembert are best consumed within a few days of purchase, as they will continue to ripen and can become too runny or develop off-flavors if stored for too long.
  • Freezing: It is not recommended to freeze Brie or Camembert, as this can adversely affect their texture. If you must freeze them, consume within a few months and allow them to defrost slowly in the refrigerator before bringing them to room temperature.

Cultural Impact

A table with a spread of brie and camembert, surrounded by wine glasses and French baguettes

As you explore the world of French cheeses, you quickly realize that Brie and Camembert aren’t just types of cheese; their cultural impact stretches far beyond their origins in France, influencing both preferences and traditions globally.

Popularity and Preference

In terms of popularity, both Brie and Camembert hold prestigious positions. Your preference might hinge on subtle differences in flavor and texture, or perhaps the allure of their French heritage.

Brie, with its rich, buttery character, has become a staple at social gatherings and is embraced worldwide for its versatility in pairing with a plethora of foods and wines.

Meanwhile, Camembert, originating from Normandy, carries a slightly stronger flavor, endearing itself to those who prefer a more pronounced taste experience.

  • Brie: Preferred for its mild, creamy texture and adaptability in recipes.
  • Camembert: Chosen for its distinct, earthy flavor and traditional enjoyment with bread and wine.

Influence on Cuisine and Traditions

The influence of these French cheeses on cuisine is undeniable. Both have woven themselves into the fabric of culinary traditions, with Brie often appearing on cheeseboards and in sophisticated dishes, while Camembert frequently stars as the centerpiece of a rustic, country meal.

  • Brie: Embedded in international cuisine; incorporated into both casual and upscale dishes.
  • Camembert: Maintains a traditional French country image; a symbol of Normandy’s gastronomic heritage.

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, you’ll find answers to some of the most common inquiries regarding Brie and Camembert cheeses, covering aspects from taste to nutritional content.

What is the difference in taste between Brie and Camembert?

Brie typically has a mild, buttery flavor, whereas Camembert offers a deeper, earthier taste with more intense mushroom and nutty undertones.

How do the prices of Brie and Camembert compare?

The price of Camembert and Brie can vary by brand and region, but generally, Camembert can be more affordable due to its smaller size and local production compared to Brie’s larger, often imported wheels.

Which is better for serving with crackers, Brie or Camembert?

Both cheeses pair well with crackers, but Brie’s creamier texture and milder flavor often make it a more versatile choice for a wider variety of crackers and accompaniments.

What are the nutritional differences between Brie and Camembert?

Nutritionally, Brie and Camembert are quite similar, offering a good source of protein and calcium. However, Brie sometimes has a slightly higher fat content due to the cream added to some variants.

Can Camembert be used as a substitute for Brie in recipes?

Yes, Camembert can substitute for Brie in many recipes as they have similar textures and melt similarly, though the stronger flavor of Camembert will be noticeable in the final dish.

Is there a notable difference in odor intensity between Brie and Camembert?

Yes, Camembert generally has a more pungent aroma compared to Brie, which has a more subtle scent. This difference in odor intensity is due to variations in their specific production processes and aging.

Follow Us
Cassie brings decades of experience to the Kitchen Community. She is a noted chef and avid gardener. Her new book "Healthy Eating Through the Garden" will be released shortly. When not writing or speaking about food and gardens Cassie can be found puttering around farmer's markets and greenhouses looking for the next great idea.
Cassie Marshall
Follow Us
Latest posts by Cassie Marshall (see all)