Capers Substitutes

Capers are a distinctive ingredient, renowned for their tangy, lemony, and slightly floral flavor. This flavor stems from their pickling process in brine or wine vinegar. Due to their intense flavor, they’re often used sparingly, yet they play a crucial role in imparting complexity to a variety of dishes.

They are commonly found in Mediterranean cuisine, adding a burst of flavor to sauces, salads, meat dishes, and are famously featured in chicken piccata. Although capers are a unique ingredient with a bold taste profile, there are times when you might need a stand-in for them in your cooking.

A jar of capers sits on a kitchen counter, next to a cutting board and knife. The lid is off, and a few capers are spilling out onto the counter

Understanding the key characteristics of capers is essential when searching for an appropriate substitute. Their briny, somewhat olive-like flavor can be emulated by several other pantry staples.

If you find yourself without capers, you can turn to alternatives such as green olives, which offer a similar salty punch. Meanwhile, kalamata olives and dill pickles provide that comparable piquancy.

Anchovies can provide a similar brininess, although they bring a fishier taste that works best in dishes where a strong umami character is desired.

Each substitute comes with its own unique flavor note and therefore might alter the final taste of your dish slightly.

To ensure the best match to the original intended flavor of a recipe that calls for capers, choose your replacement by considering the dominant flavors and textures you want to preserve or enhance in your meal.

Whether it’s a sauce, dressing, or a more complex dish, the right substitute will maintain the balance of flavors and keep your culinary creation tasting delightful.

Understanding Capers

A jar of capers sits beside a bowl of caper substitutes, with the jar's label prominently displayed

Capers are a distinctive ingredient with variations in type and size, commonly hailing from the Mediterranean region. They are integral in creating the unique flavors found in various dishes from different cuisines.

Caper Varieties

The most common type of capers, Capparis spinosa, comes in different sizes. The smallest and most sought after are the non-pareil capers, often considered superior for their delicate texture and more nuanced flavor.

On the other side of the spectrum are caper berries, which are larger, contain seeds, and are generally milder in taste.

Culinary Uses

Capers are a staple in Mediterranean cuisine and are widely used across the globe. They lend a piquant flavor to classic dishes such as chicken piccata and pasta puttanesca.

Besides these, capers are a tangy addition to tartar sauce, salads, fish dishes, and pastas.

Flavor Profile

Capers are known for their tangy, sour, and salty notes, with a hint of bitter taste that can be a unique flavor enhancer in many dishes.

The intensity of flavor varies with the size of the caper, smaller ones being more concentrated and potent, adding a touch of umami to your recipes.

Nutritional Value

Capers are low in calories and contain several beneficial nutrients. They provide a source of vitamins such as vitamin A, vitamin K, niacin, and riboflavin.

Additionally, they contain minerals like iron, calcium, and copper, making them a nutritious as well as flavorful addition to your meals.

Popular Caper Substitutes

When your recipe calls for capers and you find your jar empty, there are many alternatives you can use to mimic their distinct salty, briny, and slightly bitter flavor. Below, explore popular substitutes that can be found in most kitchens or nearby grocery stores.

Green Olive Alternatives

Green olives, specifically chopped green olives, serve as a top choice for their similar briny taste.

Kalamata olives, with a deeper hue and more pronounced flavor, can be chopped to visually and gastronomically align with capers in your dishes.

Pickled Substitutes

For that signature tangy kick, pickles such as dill pickles, cornichons, or pickled red onions are excellent in place of capers.

Using the juice of pickled items can subtly infuse the desired acidity into your recipe.

Brined Options

Caperberries, which are larger than capers and often come in a brine, can be used whole or chopped. Their size and crunch add an interesting texture variation.

Other Substitutes

Nasturtium seeds, which are edible and often pickled, provide a caper-like bite. However, they can be harder to source than other options.

Herbaceous Replacements

Replace the floral notes of capers with fresh herbs like dill or thyme—either fresh or dried. This can shift the flavor profile but still contributes a Mediterranean essence.

Citrus Accents

For a zesty twist, lemon or lime juice can add the necessary brightness to a dish.

Preserved lemons, cured in salt, also offer a complex substitute.

Miscellaneous Alternatives

Anchovies are powerful in imparting a savory, umami quality, while green peppercorns offer a milder pepperiness compared to the sharpness of capers.

Considering Acidity

Incorporating vinegar or a splash of red or white wine lends the required acidity to sauces and dressings. Their liquid form allows for easy integration into recipes.

Focus on Texture

Capers lend a unique texture to a dish, a consideration to keep in mind when choosing a replacement.

For example, caperberries provide a firmer bite, while diced green olives mimic the small size and softness of capers.

Sourcing Substitutes

Your choice might depend on availability.

Items like chopped green olives or pickles are commonly found, while options like nasturtium seeds might need to be specifically sought out.

Non-Savory Substitutes

For a less savory approach, seeking sweeter or less intense alternatives might lead you to ingredients such as artichoke hearts or sweet varieties of pickles.

Sauce Base Substitutes

In sauces or dressings where capers are a base ingredient, using more robust options such as anchovies can provide the necessary body and punch.

Recipe-Specific Recommendations

The substitute you choose should complement the flavor profile of the dish, whether it’s chicken, fish, eggs, veggies, or even antipasti.

Dishes Often Requiring Capers

Many Mediterranean recipes include capers, but with the right substitute, you can achieve a similar flavor balance.

For instance, chopped green olives can stand in for capers in a classic Puttanesca sauce.

Capers in Mediterranean Cooking

Capers are essential in Mediterranean cuisine but can be replaced with ingredients such as black olives or dried thyme to retain the regional culinary character.

Saline and Umami Additions

Optionally, ingredients that offer a salty and umami presence—like anchovies—can convincingly take the place of capers, particularly in meat or fish dishes.

Substitutes in Antipasti

In antipasti, where capers add a pop of flavor, experimenting with various pickled or brined substitutes can yield delicious results while providing similar salty and tangy accents.

Frequently Asked Questions

A stack of frequently asked questions papers scattered around a jar of capers, with a "substitutes" label in the background

In this section, you’ll find straightforward answers to common questions about caper substitutes, ensuring you can continue to create delicious dishes without missing out on the unique flavors that capers provide.

What can I use instead of capers in chicken piccata?

In chicken piccata, you can use chopped green olives to mimic the salty and briny taste of capers.

If olives are unavailable, lemon juice can offer a similar burst of tanginess.

Is there a vegetarian alternative to capers in recipes?

Yes, for a vegetarian caper substitute, try green olives, dill pickles, or artichoke hearts. These options provide a comparable flavor profile and texture to capers.

What’s an appropriate caper substitution in tartar sauce?

For tartar sauce, finely chopped dill pickles make an excellent replacement for capers. They contribute a similar tangy crunch that is typically provided by capers.

Can olives be used as a replacement for capers in dishes?

Absolutely, olives can be a suitable substitute for capers.

Pitted green olives, finely chopped, offer a similar salty, briny flavor that works well in most dishes that call for capers.

What are suitable caper alternatives for smoked salmon?

With smoked salmon, consider using finely diced red onion or chives to give a contrasting sharpness that complements the fish. Lemon zest can also provide a fresh zing as an alternative to capers.

How can I modify recipes when omitting capers?

When omitting capers from a recipe, you can adjust the seasoning with an acid such as lemon juice or vinegar. You can also add green herbs like thyme to balance the flavor profile. This will ensure your dish still has a depth of flavor.

Follow Us
Cassie brings decades of experience to the Kitchen Community. She is a noted chef and avid gardener. Her new book "Healthy Eating Through the Garden" will be released shortly. When not writing or speaking about food and gardens Cassie can be found puttering around farmer's markets and greenhouses looking for the next great idea.
Cassie Marshall
Follow Us
Latest posts by Cassie Marshall (see all)