Parsley and Cilantro are both popular herbs used for flavoring and garnishing a wide range of cuisines.
They also come from the same family: the Apiaceae or Umbelliferae family, which consists mostly of aromatic flowering plants.
This plant family is named after the type genus Apium and is commonly known as the celery, carrot, or parsley family, or 'umbellifers'. This group is the 16th-largest family of flowering plants, containing more than 3,700 species in 434 genera.
However, while these herbs may look similar, their tastes are quite different.
In this article, we’ll be exploring the little things that set these two herbs apart, including their flavor, uses, health benefits, and the dishes they’re most suited to.
Parsley or garden parsley is known formally as Petroselinum crispum and is native to the central and eastern Mediterranean region.
It is thought to originally come from Sardinia and was cultivated around the 3rd century BC.
However, since this time it has naturalized elsewhere in Europe and is today widely cultivated as both a herb and a vegetable. It is widely used in European, Middle Eastern, and American cuisine.
There are different types of parsley; curly leaf parsley is often used as a garnish - freshly chopped and sprinkled on top of dishes across Europe as well as Western Asia.
Flat-leaf parsley is used similarly, plus it’s easier to cultivate and has a slightly stronger flavor.
Root parsley is commonly used as a vegetable in many soups, stews, and casseroles and features in southern European cuisines.
Cilantro is also known as coriander, which is the name that is used in countries such as the UK, and it is also sometimes known as Chinese Parsley - another reason why it's easy to confuse these two herbs!
Cilantro refers to the vegetative stage of the plant, whereas the dried seeds are derived from later stages of the plant, known as Coriandrum Sativum, which is where the term 'coriander' comes from.
Cilantro has a bright, lemony taste to it which is quite strong, and for some people, it can be pretty controversial.
For around a quarter of those surveyed, cilantro tastes like dish soap, and this perceived taste comes from a gene that detects specific aldehydes - and these are also used in many soaps and detergents, explaining why some experience a slightly chemical, soapy taste when eating Cilantro!
Parsley is characterized by its thicker, curlier leaves which are small and pointed. However, this is curly leaf parsley, and it differs from the flat-leaved variety, which looks very similar to cilantro due to its flat leaves.
However, parsley does differ slightly from cilantro in its brighter, green-yellow color and more pointed serrations of the leaves.
Cilantro is a flat-leaf herb with a three-lobed structure in its leaves. The tips of the leaves have a saw-toothed appearance which are not quite as pointed as flat-leaved parsley and tend to be more rounded. It is also a deeper green color than parsley, often described as 'emerald green.'
This is the easiest way to tell these two herbs apart, as their tastes are quite distinctive even though they are often used to garnish similar dishes.
Parsley has a fresh, grassy smell, and the flat-leaved version is supposedly stronger, with a pepper-like taste. Curly parsley is used more for decorative purposes and has a milder, relatively bland taste.
Cilantro is known for its “love it or hate it” taste. It has a more pungent, stronger taste than parsley and that slightly soapy smell from its aldehyde chemicals.
Like we said, not everyone is a fan of cilantro, and parsley is generally more palatable, though cilantro can add a zesty finish to a meal.
Curly Parsley is popular as a garnish as it has a distinctive, ruffled texture and appearance, whereas flat-leaved parsley is stronger and is used for specific recipes.
Flat-leaf parsley is also known as 'Italian parsley' and heavily features in pasta recipes, as it is known to mitigate the creaminess of the sauces. However, it’s not just an Italian thing: flat-leafed parsley is used in a myriad of cuisines and dishes.
It’s found all over Europe, the Middle East, and North America, and is regularly used in sauces, soups, stews, salads, and egg recipes.
Cilantro features heavily in Mexican, Indian, and Middle Eastern recipes, and is usually favored for its strong flavor and aromatic smell which makes it perfect for guacamole, salsa, and chutneys, as well as pho (Vietnamese noodle soup), soups, curries, and more.
It has a distinctively fresh, emerald-green color which also makes it a popular choice for garnishing as well as flavoring meals.
These herbs do more than just make your food look pretty.
Parsley is enriched with beta carotene and vitamin C which can help protect us against harmful free radicals in the water-soluble areas of our body, and they also keep our immune system working in optimal condition.
It’s rich in B vitamins which can help prevent cardiovascular diseases, and also contains myristicin (a volatile oil) which reduces the formation of cancer-causing tumors.
For this reason, parsley is often used as a ‘chemoprotective’ food, as it protects the healthy tissues of the body from anti-cancer drugs.
It can also reduce the risk of kidney and gall-bladder related issues, as it contains a high percentage of oxalates which help protect against these.
Cilantro also offers an abundance of different health benefits
It has analgesic, antiseptic properties, and can be used as a natural stimulant and digestive aid.
It’s also rich in minerals such as calcium, which is essential for maintaining strong bones and teeth, as well as potassium which keeps blood pressure and heart rate steady.
It also contains iron which ensures the production of essential red blood cells. Like parsley, cilantro also contains high levels of beta carotene and antioxidant which helps promote good eye health as well as treat any sight-related issues.
Cilantro also has a strong metal detoxifier that helps free our body from heavy metals associated with problems such as heart problems, lung disease, stress-related illnesses, and cancer.
You might also be glad to know that cilantro contains very few calories and no cholesterol, so you needn’t hold back when it comes to sprinkling this flavorsome herb on your meals.
Differences between parsley and cilantro
- Appearance - parsley has thicker, curlier leaves, while cilantro is flatter. However, flat-leaved parsley looks very similar to cilantro
- Cilantro is usually emerald-green in color, whereas parsley tends to be more yellow-green
- Cilantro is generally stronger in flavor and has a zestier taste (likened to lemon or lime, or for some - soap!)
- In contrast to cilantro, curly-leaf parsley has quite a mild, bland flavor which is why it’s often used as a garnish for presentation purposes
- There are several varieties of parsley, but one main variety of cilantro (although the seeds are also used in cooking)
- Parsley is used mainly in European and Mediterranean cooking, whereas Cilantro is more popular in Middle Eastern, Indian, and South American cuisine
- Both herbs have many health benefits, but Cilantro has antiseptic properties, a strong metal detoxifier, and contains iron and potassium
- Parsley contains B vitamins and Vitamin C. It’s also frequently used as a ‘chemoprotective’ food.
Similarities between parsley and cilantro
- Both come from the same plant family: Apiaceae
- Both are green in color but differ slightly in tone
- Flat-leaf parsley and cilantro are very similar in appearance
- Both are commonly used as a garnish
- Both are also used in recipes for added flavor
- Both can be used in a dried form
- Cilantro and Parsley are both enriched with beta carotene, which promotes optimal eyesight and helps prevent eye diseases and issues.
Parsley and Cilantro stem from the same plant family and are suspiciously similar in their appearance. However, don’t be fooled: these herbs offer quite different tastes, and each has a distinctive flavor.
Cilantro certainly has a stronger taste though, which is why it can be pretty divisive among the population.
While flat-leaved parsley is used across Europe and features heavily in pasta recipes, the curly variety is used mainly as a garnish, and root parsley is a common ingredient in soups, stews, and other dishes.
Cilantro features heavily in Latin American, Indian, and Middle Eastern cuisine, where it is used both as a garnish and an ingredient.
Both of these herbs offer a myriad of health benefits - so they not only make your food look and taste better, but they make you feel good, too.
We hope that this article has helped distinguish the differences between parsley and cilantro, as the little things can make a big difference.
Hopefully, next time you reach for your spice rack you’ll have a better idea of whether it’s parsley or cilantro that you need, and each is equally delicious and useful in its own way. Also check out: https://thekitchencommunity.org/thyme-substitutes/