9 Equally Gooey And Runny Substitutes For Manchego Cheese

There’s nothing better than cheese. Scratch that. There is something better than cheese, and that is melted cheese. Melted cheese can provide the perfect sauce to any meal, and it can also make an excellent dip.

A lot of the cheeses that are good when they are melted are also good when they are solid, and Manchego cheese is, of course, one of these cheeses. 

9 Equally Gooey and Runny Substitutes for Manchego Cheese

But what happens if you run out of Manchego cheese and there’s none left at the grocery store? What are you supposed to do when you can’t get your hands on your favorite cheese? The answer is easy, buy a replacement. 

There are more than 600 different types of cheeses available in the world, and a lot of these cheeses are very similar to one another. 

Take Manchego cheese, for example. This cheese is of Spanish origin, and yet some cheeses are similar to it that can be found all over the world.

Manchego cheese gets its name from the type of sheep that its milk is sourced from, Manchego sheep.

These ingredients make it unique, and yet you can still find cheeses just like it that are manufactured in different countries, using ingredients from different animals. 

While you may love Manchego cheese, there comes a time when everybody fancies a change. Luckily, there are a lot of variations of Manchego cheese which are surprisingly similar to the real thing.

So if you fancy a change from Manchego cheese, but still want a gooey and runny cheese, then you’re in the right place.

In this guide, we’ve put together a list of 9 excellent substitutes for Manchego cheese which could be the perfect option for you. 

Mozzarella

The first alternative that we would recommend is Mozzarella.

Mozzarella is a cheese which is of Italian origin, however, it is a staple in dishes all over the world as it was transferred into many different cultures during the Second World War.

During the war, many Italian immigrants took Mozzarella on the journey with them which is why it has transferred into so many different cultures. 

Mozzarella is produced using the milk from either a crow or a water buffalo and because of this, it has an extremely milky taste.

However, other than the slight taste of milk, mozzarella does not have many other flavors which is why it is used in so many different dishes. 

Primarily you will find it in Italian dishes, however, thanks to the ease at which it melts, mozzarella has been introduced to lots of other meals.

So if you want a gooey and runny substitute for Manchego cheese, mozzarella is definitely one of the best options available. 

Monterey Jack 

Another great option is Monterey Jack which is of American origin. In fact, Monterey Jack was first produced in California and it was an instant hit with cheese fans across the US.

The popularity quickly grew, and now Monterey Jack is a favorite among cheese lovers worldwide.

While it is produced and sold in solid form, a lot of people will only recognize Monterey Jack when it is melted as this is the form in which it is most commonly served. 

Traditionally, Monterey Jack is of a creamy and mild flavor, however, changes have occurred to the recipe over the years, and now it is more famously known as a spicy cheese.

You can still get your hands on the traditional, mild Monterey Jack but its dry and pepper versions have definitely become the more popular choices.

So if you fancy a change from Manchego cheese, you should consider giving Monterey Jack a try. 

English Cheddar

Alternatively, you can use English Cheddar. Cheddar has an incredibly rich history in the United Kingdom, dating all the way back to the 1100s in the town of Cheddar, in England.

It has a unique taste and comes in a lot of different varieties so that you can choose the flavor which you like the best. 

Similar to Monterey Jack, you will usually buy English Cheddar in its solid form, however, it is easy to melt, and once you do you will struggle to find a gooier cheese. 

Cheddar usually has a yellow color which gives it the perfect aesthetic look when it is melted.

However, the yellow color is actually added to the Cheddar during the manufacturing process, so it is not uncommon to find cheddar that is white in color.

So if you fancy something a little bit different, and are interested in a strong taste, English Cheddar might be the perfect choice for you. 

Muenster Cheese

You may also choose to try Muenster Cheese as your Manchego Cheese substitute.

Muenster Cheese actually originates in France, but you will probably be more familiar with the American version which has become increasingly popular in recent years. 

The original Muenster gets its name from the region in France where it was first made, and the American version has simply taken the name from this.

Similar to a lot of other cheeses, the American version of Muenster is quite different from its traditional ancestor.

That being said, they are both still manufactured in a very similar way as they are both made with pasteurized whole cow’s milk.

It has a pale yellow color which is caused by the rind of the cheese, and it can range in flavor depending on the source of the cheese.

It has a soft and smooth texture when in its solid-state, and melts remarkably well, so if you want a gooey substitute for Manchego, Muenster cheese might be the best option for you. 

Asiago

Another wonderful substitute is Asiago. This cheese is another one that hails from Italy and it comes in different varieties depending on how aged the cheese is.

As it ages, Asiago cheese becomes drier and a lot more crumbly, and it is known as Asiago d’allevo. But fresh Asiago is a much smoother consistency, and it is fresh Asiago that is a good substitute for Manchego cheese.

This fresh cheese is known as Asiago Pressato, and it is sold in a fresh and soft cheese which has only matured for a handful of months.

It has a rind that can sometimes alter the color of this cheese, but most of the time Asiago Pressato will have a light brown rind which is similar to the color of straw. 

While the fresh version of this cheese is mild in taste, it has an extremely pungent smell which is created during the manufacturing process.

It is an excellent cheese for consuming when solid, grated, and even melted for a runny treat, which is why Asiago Pressato is such a wonderful substitute for Manchego cheese. 

Chihuahua

Alternatively, you could substitute your Manchego cheese with Chihuahua. Yes, you aren’t hallucinating, Chihuahua is not only a type of dog, but it is also a type of cheese.

As you would expect, this cheese originates from Mexico, and it actually comes from the Mexican State of Chihuahua which is what it is named after.

While you may expect this cheese to be slightly spicy due to its Mexican origin, this is not the case. In fact, Chihuahua cheese is actually very similar to a cheese that we looked at earlier, and that is Cheddar. 

Chihuahua cheese is very pale in color with a yellowish tint, and it tastes very similar to cheddar. It is lightly salted and has an incredibly yummy taste which is only enhanced when you consume the cheese in different forms.

While Chihuahua cheese is usually solid in form, similarly to Cheddar, it tastes incredible when it is melted, so if you want a yummy and gooey cheese, Chihuahua could be a great choice. 

Parmesan

You could also choose to give Parmesan a go. Parmesan is another Italian cheese that is famously used as the finish on a dish of pasta.

It is well known for being crumbly and having a flavor that completes a dish, but what is Parmesan actually made of?

Parmesan is not given its name because of the region it was made in, as is the case with many Italian cheeses, instead it is given its name due to the manufacturing process. 

For a cheese to be classified as Parmesan, it must be made from the milk of a cow that regularly feasts on fresh grass and hay.

The food that the cows eat affects the quality of the milk that is produced and helps give Parmesan its unique taste and texture. It also comes with a strong smell, like many cheeses do, which aids its naturally nutty taste.

While you may have only considered using Parmesan on pasta previously, it is actually excellent for using in a variety of dishes. This is why it is an excellent alternative for Manchego cheese.  

Pecorino Romano 

Next, we come to Pecorino Romano, and if you want to try a historic cheese, then this is the one for you.

The rich history of Pecorino Romano can be traced all the way back to Roman times, and because of this it is protected by European Union Law, just like Parmesan is. 

Due to the legal protection of this cheese, it has to be produced in a specific way for it to be sold under the Pecorino Romano name.

Not only that, but the law also dictates that this scrumptious cheese can only be produced in certain Italian provinces, which can make it more difficult to get your hands on. 

The production process of Pecorino Romano is the same as it was back in the Roman days, and in particular, the aging process of this cheese is vital for it to achieve its trademark taste.

To enjoy Pecorino Romano at its runniest state, you want to eat it when it is young so that it is still rubbery and soft.

This cheese does have a very unique flavor which means that a lot of people don’t enjoy it, but if you want to try some traditional Italian cheese then Pecorino Romano is a brilliant choice. 

Zamorano

Finally, we would recommend giving Zamorano cheese a try if you fancy a change from Manchego cheese. Zamorano cheese hails from Spain, and is unique to some of the other options we have looked at on this list as it is produced using sheep's milk.

This cheese is quite similar to both Parmesan and Pecorino Romano cheeses as the production process has to be very specific.

For Zamorano, the production relies on a specific type of sheep being used to source the milk as the milk must come from either Churra or Castilian sheep. 

This cheese is named after the area in Spain from which it originates, and unlike some of the other cheeses we have looked at it is very crumbly in texture.

It tastes very buttery and has a nutty twang which is partly due to the high-fat content that you will find in this cheese.

That being said, most cheeses have a high-fat content, so this shouldn’t put you off of trying Zamorano. So if you want to try something different, Zamorano could prove to be the perfect cheese for you. 

Summary 

In short, there are lots of different types of cheese that you can substitute for Manchego cheese.

While Manchego is an incredibly yummy cheese, it is always nice to try something new, and if gooey and runny cheeses are your favorite, one of these options could be perfect for you.

Latest posts by Cassie Marshall (see all)