Best Substitutes for Fontina Cheese

Fontina cheese is a versatile and beloved ingredient in various dishes, known for its smooth texture and rich, nutty flavor. It melts easily and adds a distinct aroma to recipes, making it perfect for sauces, pasta, and pizza. However, sometimes Fontina cheese may not be readily available at your local grocery store, or you might be looking for a different flavor profile or dietary alternative.

Fortunately, there are several options for Fontina cheese substitutes that can be incorporated seamlessly into your recipes without compromising taste or texture. It’s essential to understand the qualities of Fontina cheese and its role in your dishes, which makes choosing the right substitute easier. When selecting a replacement, consider factors like the melting characteristics, flavor intensity, and accessibility of the substitute cheese.

Key Takeaways

  • Fontina cheese is known for its smooth texture, nutty flavor, and melting qualities.
  • When selecting a substitute, consider factors such as flavor intensity and compatibility with your recipe.
  • Several alternatives are available that can be successfully incorporated into your dishes without compromising taste or texture.

Understanding Fontina Cheese

Origin of Fontina Cheese

Fontina cheese has its origins in the Aosta Valley, a region in the northwest of Italy. This area, known for its picturesque Alpine landscapes, has been producing this delectable creamy, rich cheese for centuries. Made from cow’s milk, Fontina cheese has earned a reputation for being a versatile and beloved Italian cheese.

Characteristics of Fontina Cheese

The appearance and taste of Fontina cheese differ slightly based on factors like age and production techniques. However, some main characteristics make it easily recognizable and sought after by cheese connoisseurs:

  • Texture: Fontina cheese is a semi-soft cheese that exhibits a creamy and smooth texture. It falls between the categories of soft cheese and firm cheese, making it incredibly versatile for various recipes.
  • Color: Fontina cheese is typically pale yellow in color, although its hue may vary slightly depending on the specific cow’s milk used. The cheese also has small, evenly distributed holes that give it a slightly spongey appearance.
  • Taste: One of the reasons Fontina cheese is so popular is its distinctive flavor profile. It has a nutty, mildly pungent taste that is both rich and buttery. Its taste intensifies as it matures, developing more complex and aromatic notes.
  • Melting Properties: Another desirable characteristic of Fontina cheese is its ability to melt beautifully, resulting in a smooth, creamy texture. This makes it a popular choice in dishes that call for melted cheese, as it blends well with other ingredients without overpowering them.

In summary, Fontina cheese is a semi-soft, pale yellow, cow’s milk cheese with a creamy texture and nutty, slightly pungent flavor. Its origins in the Aosta Valley give it a unique character, making it a perfect choice for a variety of recipes that require a flavorful, melting cheese. The next time you’re looking for a rich and savory option for your culinary endeavors, consider trying Fontina cheese to elevate your dish.

Fontina Cheese in Cooking

Fontina cheese is a versatile and flavorful ingredient that elevates various dishes. Its rich, creamy, and slightly nutty taste enhances the flavors of other ingredients, making it a popular choice in cooking.

Fontina Cheese in Pasta Dishes

When preparing pasta dishes, Fontina cheese is an excellent option. It melts smoothly into sauces, adding a delicious richness to your meal. Consider using it in creamy Alfredo sauces or in a baked macaroni and cheese. Fontina cheese is also a tasty addition to dishes with ham, chicken, or bacon, as its flavors complement these meats well.

Fontina Cheese in Soups

In addition to pasta, you can use Fontina cheese to enrich your favorite soups. It melts beautifully, providing a velvety texture and adding depth to the flavor profile of your dish. Fontina cheese is particularly well-suited for cream-based soups, such as potato, broccoli, or cauliflower.

Fontina Cheese in Sandwiches

Sandwiches are another area where Fontina cheese shines. For instance, try adding it to your next grilled cheese sandwich for an elevated twist on this classic comfort food. Combine Fontina cheese with ham, chicken, or bacon for a delightful sandwich filling that’ll have you reaching for seconds.

Fontina Cheese with Meat

Fontina cheese’s mild and creamy characteristics make it an ideal pairing for roasted meats. It melts effortlessly, creating a rich sauce that complements the flavors of the meat. You might enjoy it with roasted chicken, pork, or even beef dishes. Don’t hesitate to get creative and explore Fontina cheese’s potential in different culinary contexts.

Best Substitutes for Fontina Cheese

Gouda – The Nutty Substitute

Gouda, a popular Dutch cheese from the Netherlands, makes an excellent substitute for Fontina in many recipes. With its smooth texture and nutty flavor, it easily complements a variety of dishes. This cheese is available in varying firmness, from young and creamy to aged and hard. Choose one according to your preference and the specific needs of your recipe. Here are some key features of Gouda as a Fontina substitute:

  • Origin: Netherlands
  • Type: Dutch Cheese
  • Flavor profile: Nutty
  • Texture: Smooth
  • Fat content: Varies, typically low to medium

Gruyere – Traditional Substitute

Gruyere is a reliable substitute for Fontina, originating from Switzerland. It has a nutty flavor profile, similar to Fontina, and can be a bit expensive. However, its rich taste and high quality make it a worthwhile investment. Gruyere’s ability to melt smoothly makes it an ideal choice for recipes requiring a cheese that melts evenly. Keep in mind the following characteristics of Gruyere as a substitute:

  • Origin: Switzerland
  • Type: Swiss Cheese
  • Flavor profile: Nutty
  • Texture: Smooth and meltable
  • Fat content: Medium

Provolone – Italian Flavor

If you’re looking for an Italian alternative to Fontina, consider using Provolone cheese. Provolone has a distinct flavor, which can lend an Italian flair to your dishes. This firm cheese has a low-fat content and melts nicely, making it a versatile option. When selecting Provolone as a Fontina substitute, pay attention to these features:

  • Origin: Italy
  • Type: Italian Cheese
  • Flavor profile: Mild to sharp, depending on age
  • Texture: Firm
  • Fat content: Low

Emmental – The Versatile Substitute

Emmental, popularly known as Swiss cheese, is a great all-around substitute for Fontina. With a firm texture and low-fat content, it can be used in a wide variety of recipes. Its distinctive holes and mild yet nutty flavor make it an interesting and visually appealing choice. When using Emmental as a Fontina substitute, remember these details:

  • Origin: Switzerland
  • Type: Swiss Cheese
  • Flavor profile: Mild, nutty
  • Texture: Firm
  • Fat content: Low

Considerations When Choosing a Fontina Cheese Substitute

When you’re looking for a suitable fontina cheese substitute, there are a few key factors to consider. Three main aspects you should pay attention to are the dish type, flavor profile, and caloric content of the substitute.

Dish Type

The type of dish you’re preparing plays a significant role in determining the best fontina cheese substitute. Fontina cheese is commonly used in pasta dishes, soups, sandwiches, and as a topping for roasted meats like chicken and bacon. Consider the following:

  • Pasta dishes: For pasta dishes, Gruyère or Emmental cheese can be suitable replacements since they both melt well and complement the taste of pasta.
  • Soups: In soups, try a creamy, slightly tangy cheese like Havarti that will smoothly blend with the liquid ingredients.
  • Sandwiches and Grilled Cheese: Provolone or Gouda are good picks for sandwiches and grilled cheese due to their melting properties and balanced flavors.

Flavor Profile

Since the flavor profile of fontina cheese is a mix of nutty, tangy, and slightly sweet, it’s important to find a substitute cheese that embodies similar characteristics. Key elements of fontina’s flavor include:

  • Nutty: Gruyère, Emmental, and Swiss cheese are great for adding that nutty, earthy flavor to your dish.
  • Pungent: If you’re searching for a slightly pungent zest, blue cheese or Roquefort can be suitable substitutes.
  • Sweet and Strong: For a robust, sweet edge, consider using Gorgonzola, Taleggio, or aged cheddar.

Pay attention to the desired flavor profile of your dish and choose a substitute accordingly. Keep in mind that you can combine multiple types of cheese to achieve the desired taste.

Caloric Content of the Substitute

When it comes to the caloric content of fontina cheese, many substitutes can provide either a higher or lower calorie count depending on their fat content. In general, consider the following:

Cheese SubstituteFat Content
GoudaHigh
EmmentalMedium
ProvoloneMedium

Choose a substitute that not only matches the flavor characteristics but also aligns with the desired caloric content for your specific meal. By keeping the dish type, flavor profile, and caloric content in mind when choosing a fontina cheese substitute, you’ll be able to find the best option to bring out the best taste in your dishes.

Additional Fontina Cheese Substitutes

Mozzarella

Mozzarella is an Italian cheese that works well as a substitute for Fontina in many dishes, particularly pizzas and sandwiches. Its smooth texture and mild flavor make it an excellent choice for melting, and it is widely available in stores. Mozzarella is also a popular ingredient in grilled cheese sandwiches, as its buttery flavor complements a variety of bread types.

Taleggio

Taleggio, another Italian cheese, can be used as a Fontina substitute in sauces and fondue. Like Fontina, Taleggio has a smooth, creamy texture and melts easily. Its flavor is mild, yet distinct, making it a suitable choice for enhancing the taste of your dishes without overpowering them.

Havarti

Havarti, a Danish cheese, is a versatile option for replacing Fontina. Its smooth and buttery flavor makes Havarti an excellent choice for both sandwiches and melted cheese dishes. While not as widely known as some other cheeses, Havarti can be found in most grocery stores and is a top choice for those seeking a Fontina alternative.

Cheddar

Cheddar, a British cheese, is a widely available option for substituting Fontina. While its flavor may be more robust than Fontina’s, Cheddar’s ability to melt makes it suitable for use in sandwiches and macaroni and cheese recipes. Opt for a mild cheddar if you prefer a less tangy flavor.

Brie

Brie, a soft French cheese, can be used in place of Fontina in dishes that require a creamy, melt-in-your-mouth texture. Its subtle, earthy flavor works well in cream soups and spread on bread. If you are looking for a soft cheese alternative to Fontina, Brie is an excellent choice.

Feta

Feta cheese, made from sheep’s or goat’s milk, originated in Greece and offers a more tangy flavor compared to Fontina. Its crumbly texture makes it a great addition to salads, giving them a burst of flavor without overwhelming the other ingredients. If you want a cheese with both a mild and tangy flavor, Feta is worth considering.

Edam

Edam, a Dutch cheese, is a suitable Fontina substitute due to its mild flavor and smooth texture. It’s commonly served as a snack or appetizer, but can also be incorporated into a variety of dishes. Edam’s versatility and pleasant taste make it an attractive option for replacing Fontina.

Munster

Lastly, Munster cheese, a French cheese, can be used as a Fontina substitute in recipes requiring a smooth, melted cheese. Its gooey texture and subtle flavor make it ideal for use in fondue and similar dishes. When looking for a Fontina alternative with a silky smooth texture, consider Munster cheese.

Frequently Asked Questions

What can I use as a replacement for Fontina cheese?

You can use Gruyère, Gouda, or Provolone as a replacement for Fontina cheese. These cheeses have similar taste and texture, making them suitable substitutes.

Which cheese is closest in taste and texture to Fontina?

Gruyère is the closest in taste and texture to Fontina, with its nutty and mildly sweet flavor. It also melts well, making it ideal for cooking.

Is there a vegan alternative to Fontina cheese?

Yes, there are vegan alternatives to Fontina cheese. You can look for plant-based cheese alternatives made from ingredients like cashews, almonds, or soy. Many brands carry vegan cheese options, and they often have a similar taste and texture to Fontina.

Can I find Fontina cheese in most supermarkets?

Yes, you can find Fontina cheese in most supermarkets. It is usually located in the specialty cheese section, alongside other European cheeses.

Are there specific brands that offer Fontina cheese?

Some popular brands that offer Fontina cheese include BelGioioso, Castello, and Val d’Aosta. Many artisanal cheese producers also make Fontina cheese.

What type of dishes work best with Fontina cheese substitutes?

Fontina cheese substitutes work well in dishes that require melting cheese, such as gratins, casseroles, pizza, and pasta dishes. They are also suitable for use in sandwiches, salads, and cheese boards.

Best Substitutes for Fontina Cheese

Here's a recipe for homemade Fontina cheese
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 30 minutes
Cook Time 6 hours
Total Time 6 hours 30 minutes
Course Side Dish, Substitute
Cuisine Italian
Servings 4
Calories 122 kcal

Ingredients
  

  • 2 tbsp. cheese salt
  • 1/4 tsp. rennet
  • 2 gallons whole milk
  • 1/4 tsp. calcium chloride

Instructions
 

  • Heat the milk in a large pot over medium heat until it reaches 86°F.
  • Add the calcium chloride to the milk and stir well.
  • In a separate bowl, mix the rennet with 1/4 cup of cool water and stir well.
  • Add the rennet mixture to the milk and stir gently for about 30 seconds.
  • Cover the pot and let it sit undisturbed for about an hour, or until the curd has formed and separates from the whey.
  • Cut the curd into small cubes and let it rest for 10 minutes.
  • Increase the heat to 104°F and stir the curd gently for 20 minutes.
  • Remove the curd from the heat and let it rest for another 10 minutes.
  • Drain the whey from the curd and place the curd in a cheesecloth-lined mold.
  • Press the cheese for 6-8 hours, turning it occasionally.
  • Remove the cheese from the mold and sprinkle it with cheese salt.
  • Age the cheese in a cool, humid place for at least 3 months before serving.

Nutrition

Calories: 122kcal
Keyword substitites for fontina cheese
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!
Follow Us
Cassie brings decades of experience to the Kitchen Community. She is a noted chef and avid gardener. Her new book "Healthy Eating Through the Garden" will be released shortly. When not writing or speaking about food and gardens Cassie can be found puttering around farmer's markets and greenhouses looking for the next great idea.
Cassie Marshall
Follow Us
Latest posts by Cassie Marshall (see all)