For many, whiskey is a liquor they associate with “hard” drinking. It’s something moody gumshoe detectives drink in smoky bars or in their run down offices. However, despite this stereotype, whiskey isn’t all about doom and gloom, t can be very lively spirit when paired with the right delicious partners.
Sure, you can drink whiskey straight or on the rocks, but why not whip up good whiskey drinks that are steeped in history?
The whiskey cocktail recipes on this list run the gamut from as far back as 1688 to simple whiskey drinks of the 1800s.
We also take a tour of whiskey mixed drinks of the Prohibition Era, and we even included some modern-day easy whiskey cocktails you can use to whet your whistle.
This list of whiskey drink recipes encompasses every season. We’ve got summer whiskey cocktails and simple whiskey drinks you can use to warm your tummy in the winter.
Ready to learn how to make the best whiskey cocktails? Let’s dive into this list of the best whiskey drinks!
When you want a cocktail that’s made with an excellent Scotch, you can’t go wrong with the Rob Roy cocktail.
The Rob Roy got its start in 1894 and it’s named in honor of an operetta premier that was based on the life of Rob Roy MacGregor, a beloved Scottish folk hero.
To make the Rob Roy, you need blended Scotch whisky, sweet red vermouth, and Angostura bitters (or orange bitters).
Garnish your Rob Roy with a Luxardo cherry or Maraschino cherry.
Our best advice for making the Rob Roy is to use a really good Scotch like Dewar’s or Chivas Regal.
The New York Sour is utterly unique in the world of cocktails with the word “sour” in its name.
Also called the Maple Syrup New York Sour because it has maple syrup, this cocktail is like classic whiskey sours, but with a special something extra: a layer of wonderful red wine on top.
Although this cocktail has a modern feel, it’s believed to have been created in the 1880s by a Chicago bartender, then later popularized in NYC, which is how it came to have the New York City name.
When you pour the red wine, be sure to pour it gently on top of a spoon into the glass so that the wine floats on top.
The recipe for Blood and Sand was published in the popular and historical cocktail book published in 1930, the Savory Cocktail book.
This Scotch cocktail was named after a silent movie about a bullfighter, also named “Blood and Sand,” with the tie-in being the blood orange juice that is used to make this punchy mixed drink.
To make the Blood and Sand cocktail, you need a cherry brandy or cherry liqueur such as Cherry Heering. Be sure you don’t buy Maraschino liqueur because it gives it a totally different flavor.
When you want to close your eyes and imagine that you’re enjoying a whisky cocktail at a street cafe in the French Quarter in New Orleans, do it with the official cocktail of The Big Easy: the Sazerac.
The Sazerac is made with whiskey and sugar, but it has a surprise ingredient: absinthe, a black licorice liqueur.
This legendary whiskey cocktail may have been invented by a New Orleans apothecary named Antoine Peychaud.
To make the Sazerac, you need a good cognac, rye whiskey, a sugar cube, absinthe, and Peychaud’s bitters.
With the citrus flavors and the fresh mint leaves, this little whiskey cocktail packs a delicious punch.
This is a whiskey cocktail recipe with a long history. It was first published in a bartender guide in 1887.
It’s fun to imagine all of those Victorian-era folks enjoying this yummy cocktail. It’s a classic cocktail for sure.
To make this whiskey cocktail, be sure to muddle your mint leaves by putting the mint leaves in the bottom of your cocktail shaker and smashing them up with a cocktail muddler.
For a completely different whiskey cocktail, give the Godfather a try.
The Godfather is made with amaretto liqueur and Scotch, and those two ingredients are all it needs to be exceptional.
This cocktail is a great one to try if you want an intro to scotch that isn’t too overpowering.
Most mixologists believe that this cocktail from the 1970s was named after the “Godfather” movie because Maron Brando’s character drank Scotch a lot in the film.
Every year, more than 120,000 mint juleps are served during the weekend of the Kentucky Derby. However, you can enjoy this gorgeous mint-flavored cocktail any time of the year.
Here’s another fun fact about the mint julep: in 1784, a doctor prescribed a mint julep as a tummy ache prescription.
To make a mint julep, you need fresh mint leaves, bourbon whiskey, ice, and powdered sugar (or simple syrup).
A mint julep is primarily dry and it’s all about the bourbon.
Is a whiskey highball just a fancy name for a simple whisky soda? Not exactly.
While these two cocktails have the same ingredients and the suggested glassware is uniform, a Highball is a lot more complex than a whiskey soda.
The whiskey highball originated in a Manhattan bar in the late 19th century and was first mentioned in a New York Times article in 1904. The article said that the mixed drink was designed for people who wanted to make low-quality spirits more palatable. Ha!
Nevertheless, the whiskey highball has come into its own.
To make the whiskey highball, use good-quality whiskey, club soda (ginger beer and ginger ale also work), and a lime wedge.
Milk Punch is the oldest whiskey cocktail on this list and it dates back to Scotland in 1688. The Milk Punch cocktail was first mentioned in 1711 in a cookbook.
Also, in 1763, Benjamin Franklin recorded a version of the Milk Punch cocktail, so this is a mixed drink with a lot of history surrounding it.
To make Milk Punch, you need whole milk, bourbon whiskey, brandy, simple syrup, vanilla extract, and a cinnamon stick, star anise, or grated nutmeg for garnish.
In this list of classic whiskey cocktail recipes, we were delighted to include one whiskey mixed drink that is a true modern classic.
The Paper Plane cocktail was created in 2007 by a bartender named Sam Ross, who began making this cocktail at New York City’s Milk & Honey bar.
The Paper Plane cocktail is named after a catchy song of the same name by M.I.A. Ross says that he was listening to the song when he created this delicious cocktail.
When you make the Paper Plane for the first time, we definitely recommend listening to the song.
The Paper Plane cocktail has bourbon whiskey, Aperol, Italian amaro, fresh lemon juice, and a lemon peel for garnish.
Although it’s just whiskey that’s lightly sweetened and seasoned with Angostura bitters, the Old Fashioned has become one of the most well-known whiskey cocktails in the world.
This recipe dates all the way back to the early part of the 19th century, and there are lots of spins on this classic whiskey cocktail.
Don’t skip the sugar cube (or a teaspoon of sugar) for an Old Fashioned. It really is what makes this whiskey cocktail so special.
You can use either rye whiskey or bourbon for an Old Fashioned.
We couldn’t make a list of classic whiskey cocktails and exclude the beloved Rusty Nail.
The Rusty Nail uses Drambuie and Scotch to make the perfect stout cocktail.
Hailing from 1937, the Rusty Nail first was introduced at a British Industries Fair in 1937, where it was called the BIF (the acronym of the fair).
Interestingly, no one can even take a guess as to the origins of the unique name of this classic cocktail. Some folks have speculated that this cocktail was named after the rusty nails that may have been found on Drambuie crates.
This classic whiskey cocktail became popular in the 1960s and it’s full of flavors like honey, along with herbal notes from the Drambuie.
This classic whiskey cocktail combines whiskey’s warmth and depth with the herbal intrigue of Fernet-Branca liqueur, an Italian bitter that’s made with spices and herbs.
Unlike many bitters, Fernet-Branca has a fairly high alcohol content, clocking in at 40-45% alcohol.
To make the Toronto cocktail, you need the Fernet-Branca, rye whiskey, simple syrup (or maple syrup), and Angostura bitters. Garnish your Toronto cocktail with an orange peel.
Once you have a bottle of Fernet-Branca, you can use it to make cocktails like the Fernet Sour or the Hanky Panky. However, you can also drink it straight, apparently a trend with bartenders in San Francisco.
This is another cocktail that was invented at the hugely popular Milk & Honey bar that’s located in New York City. The bartender who created it is T. J. Siegal.
Although the Gold Rush cocktail is a modern classic, it has a fun retro feel.
If you’re looking for a truly vintage classic cocktail, you have to try the Manhattan cocktail.
This classic whiskey drink originated at a New York City club called The Manhattan Club in the 1870s.
Traditionally, rye whiskey is used to make a classic Manhattan cocktail, but you can also use bourbon for a sweeter and smoother flavor.
For a Manhattan cocktail, you need to add sweet vermouth, which is a fortified wine with liquor added to it for stabilization. Some good brands of sweet vermouth are Carpano Antica and Dolin.
Just two dashes of Angostura bitters go in a Manhattan.
A John Collins is a great cocktail for people who are just starting to try whiskey because it’s not an overpowering cocktail.
Basically, a John Collins is like a tall whiskey sour. The main difference is the club soda and the ice cubes (or crushed ice).
You can use any type of bourbon or whiskey in a John Collins. Just pick your favorite and mix it up.
To make a John Collins from scratch, you need lemon juice, simple syrup, and club soda. You can also use sweet and sour mix.
Garnish with a maraschino cherry and an orange slice.
Do you want to learn to make the perfect whiskey sour, one of our favorite easy whiskey drinks? Oh, and how about learning to make a Halekulani cocktail? Watch the video below.
Our 30+ BEST Classic Whiskey Cocktails (+Rob Roy Cocktail)
These recipes are sure to please. So, gather your family and friends and enjoy. Let us know your thoughts!
Cassie brings decades of experience to the Kitchen Community. She is a noted chef and avid gardener. Her new book "Healthy Eating Through the Garden" will be released shortly. When not writing or speaking about food and gardens Cassie can be found puttering around farmer's markets and greenhouses looking for the next great idea.
