Ricotta Salata Substitutes

Ricotta Salata is a pressed, salted, and aged derivative of whey cheese that offers a firmer texture and a saltier flavour than its fresh ricotta counterpart. Traditionally made from sheep’s milk, this Italian cheese is versatile, used in dishes ranging from pasta to salads, where it adds a touch of creaminess with a slightly salty underpinning. Its distinct characteristics can elevate a simple recipe, but what if Ricotta Salata isn’t available to you or you’re exploring alternatives for dietary preferences?

Finding a substitute for Ricotta Salata doesn’t have to compromise the integrity of your dish. In fact, a variety of cheeses can step in to fulfill the role that Ricotta Salata plays in recipes. Feta cheese is a commonly recommended alternative thanks to its crumbly texture and tangy flavour. Like Ricotta Salata, Feta can be made from sheep’s milk, although it’s often found in a version that blends sheep and goat’s milk. It can seamlessly integrate into most recipes calling for Ricotta Salata, making it a reliable and accessible choice.

Understanding Ricotta Salata

Ricotta Salata is a unique Italian cheese that serves as a delightful salted, firm version of ricotta. Known for its versatility in the kitchen, this cheese can be used in varying dishes and has distinctive features that set it apart from others.

Characteristics of Ricotta Salata

Ricotta Salata boasts a firm texture and a mild, yet salty flavor. Unlike regular ricotta, which is creamy and spreadable, Ricotta Salata is pressed and aged, giving it a crumbly texture that is excellent for grating over dishes. This firm texture also makes it a robust addition to salads and pastas.

Nutritional Profile

This Italian cheese is a low-fat option, providing protein with fewer calories compared to many other cheeses. To stay informed of your intake, consider these average nutritional values for a 1-ounce serving:

  • Calories: Approximately 90
  • Protein: Around 7 grams
  • Fat: Generally less than 6 grams

Production Process

Starting from whey left from the production of other cheeses, Ricotta Salata undergoes a process of salting and pressing before the aging. It develops a characteristic brown rind and matures into the well-loved texture and taste signature to this Italian delight.

Culinary Uses

Whether tossed in a salad, sprinkled over pasta, or served with a gratin, Ricotta Salata is a versatile cheese in Italian dishes. Due to its ability to grate finely, it’s an excellent topper for pizza or a flavor enhancer in an Italian-style stuffed recipe.

Preservation and Storage

For optimal storage, keep your Ricotta Salata in the fridge, wrapped in plastic or sealed in an airtight container, to prolong its freshness. Once cut, the exposed areas might dry out; wrapping it helps maintain both texture and flavor.

Making Homemade Ricotta Salata

If you’re unable to find Ricotta Salata, you can make a version at home with leftover whey. After the whey has been heated, strained through a cheesecloth, and pressed, the homemade Ricotta Salata should then be salt-dried. You can consume it fresh or allow it to age, based on your preference for saltiness and texture.

Ricotta Salata Substitutes

When looking for a substitute for Ricotta Salata, your focus should be on matching the cheese’s distinct saltiness and crumbly texture. Various cheeses and non-dairy alternatives offer similar flavors and textures for different culinary contexts.

Substitutes for Ricotta Salata in Salads

Feta Cheese: Ideal for salads, feta offers a crumbly texture and a salty flavor profile akin to Ricotta Salata. It is widely available and can be crumbled over fresh vegetables and cold dishes.

Cotija: With its dry, crumbly nature, Cotija is another excellent cheese to sprinkle over salads, providing a sharp, salty kick.

Alternatives for Pasta and Pizza

Pecorino Romano: Bold and salty, Pecorino Romano can be grated over pasta dishes and pizzas for a flavor that stands up well to strong Italian sauces.

Mozzarella: For slicing or melting, fresh mozzarella is a milder yet suitable option for layered pasta dishes and as a pizza topping.

Substitute Cheeses in Italian Recipes

Parmesan Cheese: Hard and granular, Parmesan can be grated or shaved into Italian recipes for a robust, salty flavor.

Asiago: Aged Asiago offers a similar flavor profile with a capacity to crumble or grate, making it versatile for inclusion in various Italian dishes.

Substitutes for Baking and Cooking

Cottage Cheese: Mild and less salty, cottage cheese can be used in baked goods, casseroles, and frittatas where a lighter cheese presence is desired.

Ricotta Cheese: Less salty than Ricotta Salata, ricotta can be incorporated into sauces, dips, and cooked dishes, offering a creamier texture.

Substitutes with a Creamy Texture

Cream Cheese: For a smooth and creamy consistency, cream cheese can substitute Ricotta Salata in spreads and dips.

Goat Cheese: Soft goat cheese provides creaminess suitable for sauces and dressings where a tangy flavor is preferred.

Dairy-Free and Vegan Alternatives

Tofu: A neutral base that can take on salty and savory flavors, crumbled tofu is a good dairy-free stand-in, especially when enriched with nutritional yeast.

Cashew Cheese: Cashew cheese, often seasoned with salt and lemon juice for tang, provides a creamy, vegan alternative that mimics the texture and flavor notes of Ricotta Salata.

Choosing the Right Substitute

Pecorino Ricotta Salata - Using Leftover Whey

When you’re looking to replace Ricotta Salata in a recipe, it’s important to consider both the texture and flavor profile of potential substitutes, as well as their salt content and relevance to the specific dish you are preparing. Health and dietary preferences also play a vital role in your choice.

Considering Texture and Flavor

Ricotta Salata is known for its firm and crumbly texture, which can be particularly important in dishes where the cheese is meant to hold its shape rather than melt. Its salty yet mildly nutty flavor contributes to both taste and texture in a recipe. Feta cheese is an excellent substitute that offers a similar saltiness and a texture that can range from creamy to firm, depending on the variety. For a less salty option, Queso Fresco can provide the crumbly aspect without overwhelming saltiness.

Accounting for Salt Content

The salt content of your substitute plays a significant role in the dish’s final flavor. Ricotta Salata has a distinctive saltiness, so if you choose a substitute like Pecorino Romano, which has a stronger salty taste, you’ll need to adjust the added salt in your recipe accordingly. On the flip side, opting for a less salty cheese gives you more control over seasoning.

Substitutes for Specific Dishes

  • Pasta: A creamy cheese like Feta maintains a creaminess suitable for pasta sauces and fillings, while still adding a tang to your dish.
  • Salad: Dry Cottage Cheese or Paneer can be crumbled into salads for a firm and crumbly texture.
  • Pizza and Sandwiches: For toppings that are solid but will melt slightly under heat, Halloumi could be a worthy alternative due to its harder texture.
  • Appetizer: When Ricotta Salata is the star, as in an appetizer board, try grating firm Goat Cheese to mimic the texture and milder flavor.

Health and Dietary Considerations

For those conscious about calories or fat content, a low-fat Feta or Tofu Feta could serve as a suitable substitute, providing a similar texture with fewer calories. Dairy-free alternatives like Vegan Cashew Cheese or sprinkling Nutritional Yeast are options for those who are lactose intolerant or looking for a substitute that provides similar nutty flavor and protein without the use of dairy.

Frequently Asked Questions

In this section, you’ll find concise answers to common queries about ricotta salata substitutes and relevant aspects, providing clarity on alternatives, availability, uses, and considerations for dietary preferences and health.

What alternative cheeses can I use in place of ricotta salata for a similar flavor and texture?

Feta cheese is the best alternative for ricotta salata, offering a similar crumbly texture and salty flavor. It’s made from sheep’s milk or a blend of sheep and goat’s milk and can be used in various dishes.

How does the taste and texture of cotija cheese compare to ricotta salata?

Cotija cheese has a saltiness akin to ricotta salata, but it is typically drier and firmer. It can be grated or crumbled over dishes and offers a robust flavor that stands out in recipes.

Can I find ricotta salata at popular grocery stores like Whole Foods and Trader Joe’s?

Ricotta salata may be available at well-stocked cheese counters in stores like Whole Foods, but its presence at Trader Joe’s can vary, so it’s recommended to check with your local store or find a specialty Italian grocer.

What are some common uses for ricotta salata in cooking?

You can use ricotta salata to add a creamy, salty element to pasta dishes, enhance salads with its tanginess, or sprinkle it over roasted vegetables and pizzas for added depth.

For vegetarians, is ricotta salata an acceptable cheese choice?

Ricotta salata can be vegetarian-friendly, but it depends on whether it’s made with animal-derived rennet. Always check the label to ensure it aligns with your vegetarian dietary preferences.

When considering health and safety, is ricotta salata typically made with pasteurized milk?

Ricotta salata is often made with pasteurized sheep’s milk, making it a safer choice for pregnant women or those concerned about consuming unpasteurized dairy products. However, confirm the pasteurization on the packaging for assurance.

Follow Us
Cassie brings decades of experience to the Kitchen Community. She is a noted chef and avid gardener. Her new book "Healthy Eating Through the Garden" will be released shortly. When not writing or speaking about food and gardens Cassie can be found puttering around farmer's markets and greenhouses looking for the next great idea.
Cassie Marshall
Follow Us